December 7 is Pearl Harbor Remembrance Day. It’s a day to honor the Americans who served and sacrificed. That comes first, always.
But veterans, circle it twice. Monday, December 7 is also the last day of Medicare open enrollment. Miss it, and in most cases you’re locked into your plan for a whole year.
And there’s one mistake I see veterans make over and over. I was making it myself.
The mistake: paying for drug coverage you never use
For years, the VA filled my prescriptions. They came in the mail, and I didn’t think twice about it.
But my Medicare plan came with drug coverage too. Coverage I wasn’t using. I was carrying two drug plans and only using one.
This fall I sat down with an AI helper and asked it to compare the Medicare Advantage plans where I live. I told it the VA fills my medicines. It pointed me to a kind of plan I’d never paid attention to: a “giveback” plan with no drug coverage at all.
I switched. Now Medicare hands me back $182 a month on my Part B premium. That’s $2,184 a year, just for not paying for drug coverage I didn’t need.
(For the curious: it’s the Humana USAA Honor Giveback PPO, plan H7617-108, here in The Villages, Florida. That’s what fits me. Your area, your doctors, and your medicines will point you to your own answer.)
Why this works for veterans
Three plain facts make it work.
1. VA drug coverage counts as “creditable.” That’s Medicare’s word for “good enough.” Medicare.gov lists VA coverage by name. So if the VA fills your prescriptions, you can skip a Part D drug plan. And if you ever need Part D later, you won’t owe the late penalty, as long as you sign up within 63 days of losing your VA coverage.
2. Some Advantage plans leave drugs out on purpose. They’re built for people who already get medicines somewhere else, like veterans. Many of them give part of your Part B premium back instead.
3. The “giveback” is real money. The plan lowers the Part B premium you pay Medicare. For most people, it shows up as a bigger Social Security check each month. You don’t have to mail anything in.
Try this: let AI do the comparing
Comparing Medicare plans means reading pages written to be hard to read. That’s exactly the kind of chore AI is good at.
Open ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, or Muse. Copy this prompt, fill in the blanks, and paste it in:
I’m a veteran on Medicare. The VA fills my prescriptions, so I don’t think I need Part D drug coverage. Please compare the Medicare Advantage plans available in ZIP code [your ZIP] for next year. Focus on “giveback” plans that reduce my Part B premium, especially plans without drug coverage. Compare them to my current plan, which is [your plan’s name, or “Original Medicare with a Part D plan”]. Make me a simple table with: monthly premium, Part B giveback amount, whether it includes drug coverage, the most I could pay in a bad year, and the copay for a hospital stay. Then tell me in plain English how much I might save in a year by switching, and what I’d give up.
Then ask a follow-up or two:
My doctors are [names]. Which of these plans should I call to check whether they’re in-network?
What questions should I ask before switching to a plan with no drug coverage?
One important caution: AI can get plan details wrong or out of date. Treat its table as a first draft. Before you switch, look up the plan you like on the official Medicare Plan Finder at Medicare.gov, or call 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227). And never type your Medicare number, Social Security number, or bank details into an AI. A comparison doesn’t need any of them.
Before you switch, check these
A giveback plan isn’t right for everyone. Run through this list first:
- Does the VA fill all your medicines? The VA generally fills prescriptions written by VA doctors. If an outside doctor prescribes something the VA won’t fill, a plan with no drug coverage means you’d pay full price at the pharmacy.
- Are your doctors in the plan? Check each one by name. Call the office and ask, “Do you take this plan?”
- What’s the most you could pay in a bad year? Every Advantage plan has an out-of-pocket maximum. That number, not the monthly premium, protects you if you get sick.
- What does a hospital stay cost? Look up the daily hospital copay. One surgery can turn a “cheap” plan into an expensive one.
- Have TRICARE? Your situation is different. Call TRICARE before changing anything.
- Keep Medicare. Even the VA says so. It covers you at non-VA hospitals and doctors, and VA funding can change. If you drop Part B, you can’t get it back until the next year.
One more thing to know: if you join an Advantage plan with no drug coverage, you generally can’t add a separate Part D plan on top of it. If you think you’ll need one, ask before you sign up.
Not signed up with the VA? Check.
Here’s what surprises people. Nearly half of all veterans aren’t enrolled in VA health care. About 9.2 million are. Roughly 5 million more are eligible and have never signed up.
Many think the VA isn’t for them. The usual myths:
- “It’s only for combat veterans.” No. It starts with your service and your discharge, not where you served.
- “It’s only for disabled veterans.” No. A disability rating moves you up the line, but you don’t need one to enroll.
- “It’s only for poor veterans.” No. Income mostly affects what you pay in copays, not whether you can join.
The basic rule from the VA: if you served on active duty and didn’t get a dishonorable discharge, you may qualify. Most people who joined after 1980 need 24 months of service, with some exceptions. Veterans exposed to toxins or burn pits during service now qualify too.
Checking costs nothing. Apply at VA.gov/health-care, call 877-222-8387, or walk into any VA clinic. Having other insurance doesn’t change what the VA will give you.
Free help, from real people
- Medicare.gov Plan Finder — the official place to compare plans.
- 1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) — answered 24 hours a day.
- Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) — free, unbiased Medicare counseling. Find yours at shiphelp.org.
Be careful with anyone who calls you about Medicare plans. Medicare won’t call you to sell a plan.
A switch isn’t right for everyone
A move like mine can be a good idea or a bad one. It depends on your situation.
You may love your doctor. If you do, that’s worth a lot. Make sure any new plan keeps them before you switch.
My own experience pushed me the other way. My primary care here was The Villages Health, now called CenterWell. In my experience, the doctors weren’t very interested in getting to the root cause of a problem. They mostly stuck with the standard tests and prescriptions the insurance would pay for. Then, after the ownership change and the fights over insurance contracts, many of the doctors I knew left. So staying put wasn’t keeping me with doctors I valued anyway.
One thing you may be wondering: CenterWell is owned by Humana, the same company behind my new plan. But my plan is a PPO, so I’m not tied to CenterWell. I can pick any primary care doctor in Humana’s network, not just CenterWell’s, and the plan even covers doctors outside the network, at a higher cost. If you’re comparing plans, ask that question too: “Am I locked into one group of doctors, or can I choose?”
Look hard at the out-of-pocket maximum. On my plan it’s $6,750 for the year, in-network. That works for me. But if you have a knee, hip, or other surgery coming up, ask yourself: could I comfortably pay that much in one year? If not, a different plan may be the safer choice.
The bottom line
If the VA fills your prescriptions and your Medicare plan also includes drug coverage, you may be paying for something you don’t use. Take 20 minutes with an AI helper, then check the result at Medicare.gov. For me, that was worth $2,184 a year.
The deadline is Monday, December 7. Honor the day. Then check your plan.
Veterans: have you ever checked whether you’re enrolled with the VA?
General information only, not financial, medical, or legal advice. Every situation is different, so confirm your choices with Medicare, the VA, or a SHIP counselor.